Isla Mujeres vs Playa del Carmen: Which is Better in 2024?

Planning a trip to Mexico and can’t decide between Isla Mujeres and Playa del Carmen? You’ve come to the right guide!

As a travel blogger that lives in Playa del Carmen, I know all about these two popular beach destinations and I’m here to share what each one is really like!

While both make amazing destinations for a beach vacation, Isla Mujeres and Playa del Carmen have some key differences, and are suited for different types of travelers.

In this ultimate Isla Mujeres vs Playa del Carmen comparison guide, I’ll share everything you need to know about how the two travel destinations compare when it comes to hotels, beaches, nightlife, safety, costs, and more.

Plus, you’ll learn more about the pros and cons of each one!

Ready to find out which of these Mexican beach destinations is best for you? Let’s get started!

When it comes to choosing between Isla Mujeres or Playa del Carmen, it’s all about what kind of vacation experience you’re looking for.

With its small size, Isla Mujeres is better if you want a more secluded and peaceful island getaway.

Its slower pace with tropical beaches and golf cart transportation make it the perfect escape from the hustle and bustle of the mainland.

On the other hand, Playa del Carmen is better if you want a mix of relaxation and excitement. It has a more developed infrastructure and a variety of resorts, restaurants, and activities to choose from.

Plus, its location on the mainland allows for easy access to other popular destinations and attractions in Riviera Maya.

Both have their own unique charm, so it really depends on what kind of vacation experience you’re looking for.

Meaning “Island of Women,” Isla Mujeres is a beautiful Caribbean island located just 15 minutes off the coast of Cancun, Mexico.

Isla Mujeres was named by the Spanish when they first arrived to the island and found many images of goddesses dating back to the time when the island was sacred to the Mayan goddess of childbirth and medicine.

At less than 5 miles long, Isla Mujeres is a small island but still offers plenty of restaurants, shopping, and accommodations. And the most popular way to get around is by golf cart!

The island is known for its stunning beaches, snorkeling excursions, catamaran sails, private yacht charters, and many adventurous Isla Mujeres activities and water sports.

The best beaches on Isla Mujeres can be found on the northwestern side of the island, most notably Playa Norte (North Beach).

I personally love getting to escape to Isla Mujeres on a day trip or for an overnight stay–it’s a true island paradise!

Playa del Carmen, Mexico is a laid-back beach destination located on the Caribbean coast of the Yucatan Peninsula just 1 hour south of Cancun.

Originally a small fishing village, the town has grown rapidly in recent years with a large expat and digital nomad community.

But even with its growing population and busy touristy areas, Playa del Carmen (known simply as “Playa” to locals) still feels like a small Mexican beach town.

It’s known for its stunning turquoise waters, white sand beaches, and lively main street known as Fifth Avenue (“La Quinta Avenida” in Spanish).

There are also many restaurants, bars, and shopping in Playa del Carmen–all within short walking distance of the beach, making it a great place to explore and relax.

I love living in Playa del Carmen as it places you in the heart of the action but you still have easy access to beaches, cenotes, and other natural wonders of the region.

To get to Isla Mujeres from the Cancun Airport, you’ll need to take ground transportation to the Isla Mujeres ferry terminal in Cancun.

You can choose the Ultramar Ferry at Puerto Juarez or the Xcaret Xailing ferry in the Cancun Hotel Zone, then it’s about a 15-20 minute ferry ride over to Isla Mujeres.

Alternatively, to get to Playa del Carmen, you’ll need to book a Cancun airport private transfer and drive approximately 1 hour south from Cancun to Playa del Carmen.

Playa del Carmen is much more accessible and gives you easy access to all the activities and attractions on the mainland.

Isla Mujeres is a popular tourist destination for people who are looking for a quiet and relaxing getaway.

The beautiful island has incredible beaches, crystal-clear water, and there are plenty of things to do in Isla Mujeres to keep visitors busy.

Isla Mujeres is perfect for couples or families who are looking for a relaxing vacation.

The island has plenty of activities, but it’s also small enough that you can easily find a quiet spot to relax.

And with its small size and golf cart transportation, it definitely has more of a remote island vibe.

If you’re looking for a party scene, Isla Mujeres is probably not the best place for you as the island is more quiet and laid-back with limited nightlife.

Playa del Carmen is best suited for travelers who are looking for a livelier destination and want to be closer to the action.

With its vibrant 5th Avenue and many options for restaurants, shopping, and nightlife, visiting Playa del Carmen is perfect for travelers who are seeking a beach destination but still enjoy being out and about.

And with its wide range of accommodations, Playa del Carmen appeals to many different types of travelers whether you’re on a budget, looking for something luxurious, or anywhere in between.

Playa del Carmen is also a great central hub for exploring other parts of Mexico, which makes it a great destination for solo travelers and digital nomads.

The official U.S. Department of State Travel Advisory for both Isla Mujeres and Playa del Carmen is currently “Level 2 – Exercise Increased Caution” due to the high levels of crime and violence in the overall state of Quintana Roo.

The United States Mexico travel advisory mentions that criminal activity and violent crime may occur in popular tourist destinations such as Cancun, Playa del Carmen, and Tulum, but does not specifically list Isla Mujeres as an area of risk.

Numbeo reports the following crime and safety indices for Isla Mujeres and Playa del Carmen. Basically you want the crime index to be low and the safety index to be high.

• Crime Index: Isla Mujeres: 14.71 (Very Low) | Playa del Carmen: 46.89 (Moderate)
• Safety Index: Isla Mujeres: 85.29 (Very High) | Playa del Carmen: 53.11 (Moderate)

🚨 Do you need travel insurance for Mexico? Yes! Most insurance plans in your home country will not cover incidents abroad. I recommend using Travel Insurance Master, which is a handy travel insurance marketplace where you can compare policies. Get a FREE quote by clicking here!

Yes, Isla Mujeres is generally safer than Playa del Carmen. Isla Mujeres has a much lower crime rate and higher safety index than Playa del Carmen, making it the safer choice for travelers.

When it comes to staying safe in Isla Mujeres, you’ll still need to be mindful of your surroundings, but you should feel much safer than in Playa del Carmen.

Since Isla Mujeres is more remote and less populated, it is very peaceful and quiet with limited nightlife.

Playa del Carmen has a much more robust nightlife scene, which makes it more prone to crime and illegal activity.

I don’t feel unsafe living in Playa del Carmen but I’ve learned to live very cautiously by following these Playa del Carmen safety tips and avoiding the drug scene.

A vacation to Isla Mujeres might be a bit cheaper than Playa del Carmen, but both destinations are pretty comparable when it comes to cost.

In terms of lodging, you’ll find that Isla Mujeres is generally cheaper than Playa del Carmen, mainly because the island doesn’t have many all-inclusive resorts.

And while Isla Mujeres is closer to Cancun Airport, it will probably cost the same amount as an airport transfer to Playa del Carmen, considering you’ll need to book a transfer to the ferry, plus ferry tickets, and then a taxi to your hotel.

But if you rent a golf cart once you get there, you can use that as your main form of transportation and save money on transportation costs.

Playa del Carmen, on the other hand, has many all-inclusive resorts that can be much more expensive. But there’s also plenty of more budget-friendly options as well.

And in both destinations, you’ll find a wide selection of restaurants, bars, and activities to choose from that will fit all budgets.

💳 One important thing to know is that credit cards are not widely accepted in Isla Mujeres (especially at restaurants and beach clubs) so you should make sure to bring enough cash with you to avoid added credit card fees.

Playa Norte on Isla Mujeres has been voted as one of the best beaches in the world and offers powder white sand and very calm and shallow turquoise water–it is unbelievably beautiful!

Plus, what makes Playa Norte so popular is that it rarely gets hit with the seaweed that can commonly plague other beaches in Riviera Maya.

Now Isla Mujeres beaches on the west side of the island have rocky coastlines and aren’t really suitable for swimming, but the east side has plenty of white-sand beaches perfect for swimming and soaking up the sun.

On the other hand, the beaches in Playa del Carmen are still very nice, but the ones in the downtown area can be very crowded and congested.

And the beach clubs in Playa del Carmen can have a bit more of a party vibe, and aren’t as laid back as the ones in Isla Mujeres.

Plus, depending on the time of year, there can sometimes be large amounts of seaweed on Playa del Carmen beaches.

Isla Mujeres is much more compact and mainly has smaller boutique hotels and vacation rentals–both in the town center and on the beach.

Aside from Mia Reef Isla Mujeres, the island doesn’t really have any large all-inclusive resorts and it’s easier to find budget hotels.

The hotels in Isla Mujeres provide more affordability as you won’t be paying for an all inclusive plan but can be more limiting when it comes to amenities and services.

And the hotels on Playa Norte are located in a livelier area while hotels on the southern part of the island offer a more relaxed and quiet experience.

Here are some of the best places to stay in Isla Mujeres for every budget:

• Luxury: Casa del Jaguar Beach Hotel 
• Mid-Range: Hotel Belo Isla Mujeres
• Budget: Icaco Island Village

Travelista Tip: If you’re looking for walkability, you’ll definitely want to stay at a hotel on or near Playa Norte, as it’s right next to the downtown area.

On the other hand, Playa del Carmen has a much wider range of accommodations with luxury all inclusive resorts, boutique hotels, and condos for rent.

So if you want to spend your vacation at a sprawling Playa del Carmen all inclusive resort with lots of amenities and activities, Playa del Carmen is the better choice.

But at the same time, if you’re looking for a smaller hotel or vacation rental within walking distance of the beach and town center, you’ll find that in Playa del Carmen too.

Overall, the hotels in Playa del Carmen provide more variety but can also be a bit pricier than Isla Mujeres depending on the type of accommodation you choose.

Here are some of the best places to stay in Playa del Carmen for every budget:

• Luxury: Mahekal Beach Resort
• Mid-Range: Hotel HM Playa del Carmen
• Budget: Serenity Hotel Boutique

Travelista Tip: If want to stay in downtown Playa del Carmen, I would recommend staying near 5th Avenue but not right on it as it can be very noisy.

Both Isla Mujeres and Playa del Carmen offer a ton of fun activities from snorkeling and scuba diving to exploring Mayan ruins.

But Playa del Carmen’s mainland location makes it much easier to explore all the fun things to do in Riviera Maya and the surrounding Yucatán peninsula.

Here’s an overview of some of the activity highlights in each destination:

These are some of the best things to do in Isla Mujeres:

• MUSA: Located near Isla Mujeres, the MUSA Underwater Museum of Art offers visitors the chance to snorkel and scuba dive at a man-made underwater museum and sculpture park designed to promote the growth of coral reefs.

• Swimming with Whale Sharks: During the months of May-September, whale sharks arrive to the island of Isla Mujeres to feed in the plankton-rich waters off the coast of the island, offering visitors the chance to swim alongside these gentle giants for an unforgettable whale shark snorkeling experience.

• Playa Norte: The most popular beach on the island, Playa Norte on Isla Mujeres is perfect for swimming, sunbathing, or relaxing at a beach club. With clear turquoise water and powder white sand, it’s your quintessential Mexican Caribbean beach experience.

• Punta Sur: Punta Sur is the southernmost tip of Isla Mujeres, and is home to a beautiful lighthouse, sculpture park, restaurants and shops, and breathtaking views. With a small entrance fee, it is essentially an island landmark and one of the top places to visit in Isla Mujeres.

These are some of the best things to do in Playa del Carmen:

• Xcaret Parks: Many of the Xcaret adventure parks can be found just south of Playa del Carmen including Xcaret, Xplor, Xplor Fuego, Xel-Ha, and Xenses, offering a variety of adventure and water activities.

• Cenotes: There are many incredible cenotes near Playa del Carmen, which are freshwater swimming holes that are unique to Mexico’s Yucatan peninsula. These natural wonders offer visitors the chance to swim, snorkel, and explore the incredible underground caves formed over thousands of years.

• Mayan Ruins: The Tulum Ruins site is one of the closest Mayan Ruins to Playa del Carmen and the only beachfront Mayan Ruins in the state of Quintana Roo. Additionally, Chichen Itza is one of the largest archeological sites in the Yucatan peninsula and located about 2 hours from Playa del Carmen so it’s easiest to visit on a Chichen Itza Ruins tour.

• Akumal: Located halfway between Playa del Carmen and Tulum, Akumal is a small coastal town where you can swim with sea turtles in their natural habitat directly off the beach. It’s one of the best Playa del Carmen snorkeling tours, where you can see them up close.

If you are a foodie and want to have some great meals during your vacation, then Playa del Carmen is definitely the place to be.

There are many great restaurants in Playa del Carmen ranging from casual taquerias serving up Playa del Carmen’s best tacos to high-end fine dining restaurants, offering a variety of delicious cuisines.

In fact, most of my favorite restaurants in Playa del Carmen are actually Italian or pizza restaurants! But what’s great is that there is a wide variety of cuisine to choose from.

In Isla Mujeres, there is still good food to be found but the range is a bit more limited, and outside of hotels, the majority of restaurants are located in the town center along Avenida Miguel Hidalgo.

During the day, you’ll probably be sticking to standard beach club fare like tacos, burgers, and sandwiches. And there are some cute breakfast spots too.

But overall, the local restaurants in Isla Mujeres tend to be more casual and less adventurous than those in Playa del Carmen.

If you’re looking for more variety and more options to choose from, Playa del Carmen is the place to go!

When it comes to nightlife, Playa del Carmen definitely has the edge over Isla Mujeres.

Overall, Isla Mujeres is a very quiet and laid back beach destination with limited nightlife.

You’ll still find bars and restaurants open at night in the town center but it’s nothing too crazy, and most people just prefer to hang out and day drink at the beach clubs.

On the other hand, Playa del Carmen has a vibrant nightlife scene with tons of bars and nightclubs open late into the evening.

Plus, you can also see the famous Coco Bongo show, Joyà by Cirque du Soleil, or the Xcaret Mexico Espectacular production at Xcaret Park.

Here are the answers to some of the most frequently asked questions about Playa del Carmen and Isla Mujeres:

I hope this article has helped you decide whether to visit Isla Mujeres or Playa del Carmen for your next trip!

Both destinations offer their own unique experiences and are definitely worth visiting.

If you’re looking for a relaxing beach getaway with some incredible beaches, then Isla Mujeres is the best choice.

Its small island vibe and golf cart transportation make it a great spot to unwind and relax.

On the other hand, if you’re looking for a livelier destination with beaches, nightlife, restaurants, and easy access to activities, then Playa del Carmen is definitely the better option.

And if you do choose Playa del Carmen, you can still considering visiting Isla Mujeres on a day trip or taking a tour to Isla Mujeres from Playa del Carmen.

But no matter which destination you choose, you really can’t go wrong and are sure to have an amazing time!

READ NEXT:

• Playa del Carmen vs Cozumel
• Cozumel vs Isla Mujeres
• Cancun vs Isla Mujeres